Greener BeeGreen HolidaysAre Schools Banning Valentine’s Day Because it Offends Muslims?

CLAIM

At least one state banned Valentine’s Day at schools because it is offensive to Muslims. See Example(s)

EXAMPLES

there is a rumor that some schools are cancelling Valentine’s Day because it is offensive to Muslims.




mostly false

RATING

mostly false

WHAT’S TRUE

In January 2016, a single school in St. Paul discontinued Valentine’s Day celebrations in keeping a 2008 policy discouraging classroom observances (including birthdays).

WHAT’S FALSE

The policy extended to all non-federal observances, and did not originate with Muslims.

ORIGIN

On 15 February 2017, the web site LibertyIsViral.com reported that the state of Minnesota had banned Valentine’s Day, specifically because it “offends Muslims”:

Guess Which State Just BANNED VALENTINES DAY Because It ‘OFFENDS MUSLIMS’ … SERIOUSLY

WTF?! SINCE WHEN DID AMERICA BECOME FILLED WITH THE MOST VILE OPPRESSIVE ASS BACKWARDS PUSSIES ON THE FACE OF GOD’S GREEN EARTH? THIS IS STARTING TO MAKE ME FURIOUS. AMERICANS NEED TO GET THEIR HEADS OUT OF THEIR ASSES AND THEIR KIDS OUT OF GOVERNMENT RUN SCHOOLS BEFORE THEIR CHILDREN ARE TURNED INTO SHEEP.

The Principal of Bruce Vento Elementary School in St. Maul, Minnesota just sent a letter to parents noting that celebrations of Valentine’s Day are banned.

Why? Because it, along with other “dominant holidays,” are offensive to Muslims! … The principal went on to explain the holiday is cancelled as it violates some students’ religious beliefs. This is a reference to Muslims are not allowed to celebrate it. The romantic holiday is outlawed throughout every Islamic nation … Schools are never this sensitive to the needs of Christian students, but liberal school administrators will stop at nothing to appease Muslims. This is outrageous!

According to the misleading story, the principal at Bruce Vento Elementary School in St. Paul banned Valentine’s because it offended Muslims, citing a 29 January 2016 article published by the Star Tribune. That article began:

Celebrations of Valentine’s Day and the other “dominant holidays” are ending at one St. Paul elementary school, according to a letter from the principal addressed to families.

Principal Scott Masini of Bruce Vento Elementary School, whose student body is overwhelmingly nonwhite, explained in the letter that “my personal feeling is we need to find a way to honor and engage in holidays that are inclusive of our student population … I have come to the difficult decision to discontinue the celebration of the dominant holidays until we can come to a better understanding of how the dominant view will suppress someone else’s view.”

Masini said there will be no cards or treats brought to school to mark Valentine’s Day.

The letter listed the holidays that the East Side school will no longer celebrate as Halloween, Thanksgiving, Christmas and Valentine’s Day. Masini said the decision was made in consultation with his staff.

“One of the concerns that I have,” Masini wrote, “ … is whether or not this practice is encroaching on the educational opportunities of others and threatening the culture of tolerance and respect for all.”

The reason the original piece pointed out the proportion of “nonwhite” pupils at the school was not clear, as religion and melanin content are not interchangeable. Statistics provided in the article showed that Asian-American and Pacific Islander students were in the majority at 52.3 percent (a large percentage of whom identify as Christian). The second and third largest demographics at 35.4 and 6.9 percent respectively were black (also Christian) and Hispanic (again, largely Christian). Masini made no reference to Islam or any other religion in the entirety of the article, and the single sentence about to religious objections came from comments made by a Facebook user in support of the policy change:

The letter surfaced Wednesday evening on an invitation-only Facebook page titled “Supporting St. Paul Students and Teachers.” By daybreak Thursday, there were dozens of comments left on the page, which was started by parents in the district two years ago in connection with teacher contract talks.

“Very sad. All the fun is gone,” read one posting. “Totally ridiculous” and “Tired of the PC,” read two others.

In support, one commenter said she believes Masini and his staff are “being sensitive to children at their school who do not practice these holidays due to religious beliefs. … Holidays are very personal. Every family has a different take on how they celebrate or do not celebrate them.”

Left out of the 2017 rehash of the 2016 article was its background about the district’s overall policy regarding classroom observance of holidays across the board, put in place nearly a decade before anyone claimed that offended Muslims were to blame:

School board policy regarding holidays, last revised in 2008, says that schools “shall discourage lavish programs and festivities arranged to celebrate holidays and other special days, and shall strive to eliminate them, if possible except where such observances are required by law.” Those holidays: Washington’s Birthday, Lincoln’s Birthday, Martin Luther King’s Birthday and Veterans Day … The district eliminated student birthday party celebrations a few years ago to ensure inclusiveness, meaning no more goodies brought into classrooms on special days, [district spokesman Tony] Taschner said.

We found no information whatsoever to suggest that the primary claim (that offended Muslims ordered the cancellation of Valentine’s Day at one school or an entire state) had any basis in truth. That decision was covered by an area newspaper in January 2016 (not February 2017), and the reasons it was revisited as if novel were not apparent.The claim appeared to be a rehash of routine allegations that offended Muslims have demanded or coerced (non-existent) bans on Christmas, the Pledge of Allegiance, poppies, the National Anthem, the American flag in America, the Statue of Liberty, Halloween (twice), bathing suits at water parks, bacon, England jerseys, pork, ham, the graves of grandparents, chapel benches, and the use of microwaves for non-halal food.

Sources:

Walsh, Paul.   “St. Paul School Kisses Valentine’s Day, Other ‘Dominant Holidays,’ Goodbye.”
StarTribune.   29 January 2016.

PewResearchCenter.   “The Shifting Religious Identity Of Latinos In The United States.”
7 May 2014.

PewResearchCenter.   “A Religious Portrait Of African-Americans.”
30 January 2009.

PewResearchCenter.   “Asian Americans: A Mosaic Of Faiths.”
19 July 2012.

Article source: http://www.snopes.com/schools-banning-valentines-offends-muslims/


Comments

Are Schools Banning Valentine’s Day Because it Offends Muslims? — No Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *